theorem ← Back to Theorem

The record

From September 15, every call this engine makes is logged and graded in public — that's the record that matters. Behind it: 13 seasons of pre-registered testing (2012–2024), and a sealed 2025 that no method touches until it's spent as the next clean confirmation.

Every public number Theorem prints traces to this page or the prediction log behind it — no exceptions, no rounding up. When someone asks whether the engine is any good, this URL is the answer.

Tested on seasons the methods never saw. Selection ran walk-forward on 2012–2023. Each family got one confirmation run on held-out 2024, now spent. 2025 is sealed — never evaluated, only consumed as input.
Bars declared before the run, never moved after. A near-miss is a miss. Nothing gets re-scored once the result is in.
Failures ship too. As honest copy, as displayed facts with no lean attached, or as graves below.

Precision note: methods were tested on 2012–2024 — walk-forward selection on 2012–2023, one held-out confirmation on 2024. 2025 is consumed as input only, never evaluated.

The live record — starts with week 1

AS OF AUGUST 2026 · PRE-SEASON

The record starts with week 1. Every call the engine makes is logged before games kick off, graded against what actually happened on the Tuesday after, and printed here: what we said, what happened, and the one fact that explains the gap.

Misses print at the same size as wins, and every miss names its owner: the field, or us.

0 CALLS GRADED · WK 1 PENDING

Three ranking methods were pre-registered before week 1 and are graded every week against the same actuals; the winner ships next season. That race is internal and not shown here.

Everything below is the historical testing record that decided what ships.

What shipped, and its record

Draft board — top of the draft
Market consensus (ADP) beat our production baseline at podium capture in 10 of 11 seasons (2013–2023), confirmed on held-out 2024
10 of 11
Draft board — deep rounds
Past the ~150 players the market prices, last season's production beat ADP at deep-pool ordering all eleven years
11W–0L
QB streaming
Ranking available QBs beat “grab the injured starter's backup” in 23 of 24 season-comparisons, and beat season-average for rest-of-season picks (8 of 12). The 3-week bridge ranking failed its gate and is not shown
23 of 24
Defense composite
Ranks available defenses better than season-average alone, validated three times. Does not claim streaming beats holding a good defense — that depends on the defense you already roster
validated 3×
Waiver radar
Flagged players hit 2+ startable weeks in the next 4 at ~30% vs an ~12% base rate for the available pool (~2.6× lift, 2012–2023). Availability gate: 11W–1L. It does not claim to beat points-chasing on a clean pool — that came out statistically even, and an earlier 2.5× figure is retired
11W–1L
Kicker
Season scoring rate and volume only. No weekly matchup claim — that layer failed validation; its grave is below
season-level only

Near-ties — the only leans in the product

When two players project within a point of each other, the projection has nothing left to say. Two leans survived testing — barely — and ship at their pooled honest rates, never the selection-flattering ones. A 51.5% lean is a coin flip with a thumb on it, and the product says so in place.

Soft-opponent lean
Pooled 51.5% over ~8,150 near-tie pairs (2012–2024). Selection ran 11W–1L; the 2024 confirmation was 50.1% — a letter-pass. The pooled number is the one we print
51.5%
Game-script lean
Favored → runner, underdog → pass-catcher. Pooled 51.1% over ~3,500 pairs; the 2024 confirmation was 57.6%, the best of the cycle, and the pooled number is still the one we print
51.1%
TD rate at the tie margin
Chasing TD history at the tie margin lost its gate. TD rate displays as a fact and earns no lean
2W–9L

Eight projections walked in. Season average walked out.

Before any of the above, the first gate was the projection itself. Eight variants — recency blends at two weights and two windows, opponent-adjusted versions, an opportunity-times-efficiency model, and blends of those — ran on thirteen seasons against the plainest baseline in fantasy: a player's season average. The baseline won. Every cleverer variant lost or landed within noise of it, so the engine runs the plain number and says so.

blend 60/40 + opp adjburied blend 60/40buried blend 30/70buried blend 30/70 last-5buried season avg + opp adjburied opportunity × efficiencyburied 50/50 opportunity blendburied

That test never ended. It became the gate every idea below had to face.

The graveyard — tested, failed, not sold to you

Every method here entered a pre-registered gate — success bars declared before the run, judged on seasons it never saw. These are the ones the bars killed, with the numbers that killed them.

Hybrid draft board: market order up top, production order deep — where the crowd prices well, use the crowd; where it stops pricing, use the data
SHIPPED · podium 10 of 11 · deep 11W–0L
Opponent-aggregate adjustment — two independent builds, same grave
0W–12L, twice
Vegas lines, level form — betting-market levels as a weekly input
1W–11L
Vegas deviation form — buried at the pre-registered clamp margin (2.66%). The only grave with a resurrection clause: a revival is pre-registered for next season's boundary, declared in advance
buried at the margin
Usage-vs-points waiver blend — every blend weight tested
dominated by points-only
TD-rate tiebreak — regression bait at the tie margin; ships as a displayed fact, no lean
2W–9L
Draft corrections v1, rate-only — ignored volume and availability. Its podium 7W–4L is a boarded next-cycle hypothesis, not a feature
1W–10L pool
Draft corrections v2, totals-scaled — nearly tied, and nearly isn't a reason to ship
5W–6L, both gates
Context bundle (home + weather) — won rank quality by a hair, lost lineup points by 2.9. The projection is unchanged, and that is the gate working
failed confirmation
Better-team tiebreak — 8W–4L in selection, 46.4% on the 2024 confirmation. Dead permanently
46.4% on confirm
QB 3-week bridge matchup ranking — did not clear its own target
7 of 12
Weekly kicker matchup layer — all three pre-registered criteria failed; weekly kicker outcomes are close to pure noise, a fact about the position
no signal

Most sites bury their misses. We bury ideas — publicly, with the numbers that killed them.

The fine print on our own performance

Numbers a marketing page would leave out. This page is not a marketing page.

The waiver radar's 2024 window was ugly. Its short-window hit rate that season was 11.3% against an 11.9% base rate. The pooled claim above includes 2024 — no flattering windows.
The AI's instincts lost to the gates. Stated priors from the model that helped build this ran roughly 1-for-4 across the testing cycle, and are recorded as such. Gates outrank intuition here — including the intuition of the tool that built the gates.
One run was voided. A “v2” experiment silently re-executed v1; identical-to-the-decimal records were the tell. The result was struck and the retry run for real. A gate result only counts if the instrument actually ran.

The rules going forward

Engine 1.0 is frozen for the 2026 season and the ordering froze before week 1 — a record you can't game by retraining away the misses. Facts update weekly (injuries, roles, usage, byes); the method holds still.

Frozen is not finished. From week 1, alternative methods run in shadow — logged before kickoff and graded against the same actuals as the live engine. After the first six weeks of real results we re-evaluate: anything that beats the shipped method on the season's own data ships as a versioned public release, announced, with its own record starting from zero. 1.0's record stays exactly as graded — improvement never edits the record.

PRE-REGISTERED MARGINSHOLD-OUT SEASONS ONE CONFIRM RUN, SPENT DELIBERATELY METHODS TESTED 2012–20242025 SEALED WK-6 RE-EVALUATION · SHIPS VERSIONED